Need help picking a...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Need help picking a controller

39 Posts
18 Users
0 Reactions
13.4 K Views
Posts: 136
Topic starter
(@blk69)
Estimable Member
Joined: 10 years ago
[#42483]

Could really use some help here. Have a much better understanding now of how RGB control works. I'm ready to take my first baby steps and get a controller, power suppy and some more RGB strips. Wanting to get something I can grow with.

To start, looking for a 27ish channel dumb RGB pixel controller, 12 VDC. On the fence with Ethernet 3.1 protical vs straight DMX. Look's like some folks are having success with running cat5 so 3.1 maybe (RJ45 jacks looks easier to work with, maybe they aren't outside...don't have a clue). I really have not looked into this much so looking for help. Will be getting a Ras PI as the PC and using Vixen or Xlights. Found a few controllers in the $50 to $70 range (saw a few you tube video reviews from Leechburg lights). They all looked the same to me. Any brand out there more durable for a newbe. Will not exceed 300 pixels per channel.

In the future would like to add more dumb rgb controllers and some smart pixel controllers. Appears to get good fading on the smart pixels need to go with the 8 bit format (vs 5 bit). Thinking will standardize on the WS2812B pixels (again not sure whats best, these look like the latest and greatest).

Found some really cheap 3 channel controllers (around $10). Looks like more cost effective to get a high number channel board. Again I am not sure. Will probable end up with a bunch of stuff as I grow, asking for help to keep some of my clutter down.

Ok on the power supply...a watt is a watt. As for the pixels, got some nice strips last year (water proof) will get some more. Got like 10M (30 pix/m), a power supply and a basic controller for around $20. Have to toss the controller but seams like a good deal for the strip.

Any help/insight would be greatly appreciated.


38 Replies
TazChaLet
Posts: 3042
(@tazchalet)
Famed Member
Joined: 13 years ago

your rgb strips are they dumb strips or smart pixels?


Reply
dpitts
Posts: 1020
(@dpitts)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

Here is a link to a comparison of RGB controllers.

http://xlights.org/rgb_controllers/


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago

There are basically two types of RGB we generally use. Dumb RGB and Smart RGB.

Dumb RGB led(incandescent lights too, usually 3 intertwined colors) have a common wire and 3 color wires, R, G and B for a total of 4 wires. All LEDs on the string/strip light the same color and all at the same time. You can't do chases or multiple colors on the same string. The whole string is off or on and its all red, purple, yellow, green, etc. Not some of red and some of blue. The way it works is the controller sends power from 0 to 5v or 0 to 12v (depending on the string) to each of the 3 color wires. So to turn them all red, it sends 5v on the red wire and nothing on the blue and green. To make them turn on magenta (pink), the controller powers on the red wire and the blue wire and nothing on green, thus mixing red and blue to make magenta. Its also capable of mixing at lower values. For example a nice Halloween purple might be produced by 3v on the red and 5v on the blue (more blue than red), and 0 on green.

Dumb RGB strands consume 3 channels on a controller no matter if there is one LED or 100 LEDs. They all come on and go off at the same time. They are typically cheaper due to the fewer parts involved in manufacturing them.

Smart RGB, or what most call "pixels", usually have 3 wires (some have 4 but majority have 3). There is a ground, a V+ (either 5v or 12v), and a signal. Smart RGB has the advantage of being able to control each LED individually. This makes patterns like chases possible. You can turn on 1 or 100. You can have 1 red and 99 blue. The possibilities are much more expanded over dumb RGB. But it requires a completely different controller. Instead of sending actual voltages to light the LEDs, the controller must send a packet of data down the data line. Each pixel has a chip, hence why its called "smart". Each chip takes the data sent to it, and strips off 3 channels (R, G and B) and passes the remaining data down the wire to the next pixel which does the same, and so on.

Smart RGB strands consume 3 channels for EVERY pixel on the strand. A strand of 50 pixels consumes 150 channels but do so on only 3 wires. Depending on the controller you can control anywhere from 170 to over 1000 pixels on a single wire.

I don't know of any controllers that do both dumb and smart pixels at the same time. Not sure you would want one anyway.

So far none of that is DMX or e1.31. These two protocols are how you get data TO the controller. The controller's job is to take those protocols and convert them to whatever type of outputs the controller runs, either dumb or smart RGB. You can have a DMX Smart Pixel controller AND you can have a DMX Dumb RGB controller, and you can have them on the same DMX wire chain! There are also e1.31 controllers for both smart and dumb RGB strips. And there are even e1.31 to DMX (called bridges) devices. And here are controllers out there that send data to smart pixel strands and also have DMX outputs so you can hook up even more widgets.

There are folkx who do only dumb RGB and incans and put on a hell of a show with them. There are others who only use smart RGB pixels and put on a hell of a show. And there are still others who have both, and their shows are just as awesome! What I am saying is just because you start with dumb strips and a cheap controller, does not preclude the possibility of adding a smart pixel controller to your show and keeping the old controller. They can frequently coexist just fine in your yard. I have never heard of a smart controller pulling up stakes and walking off because you laid down a dumb RGB controller beside it. They do different things with different types of lights.


Reply
Posts: 127
(@t-jo13)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago

First off you have to look at the future and what you want to do. Lets say after a year or 2 you decide you dont want to do it anymore. Dumb rgb strips are about worth nothing so all the money you spent on dumb rgb will yield you very little if anything. Now if you buy smart rgb equipment, that is rather easy to sell and you can get much more back on it. Then there is the fact that you will get rather bored with just changing color, as that is all that dumb equipment can do. Now with smart rgb you can take one strip and make it do alot of things . I am rather sold on falcon boards so i am just posting my opinion. You can buy a 4 port controller @115.00 and one good power supply (meanwell ) for around 40.00 and that will keep you happy for awhile for under 200.00. Now if you plan on growing then you can get a f16v2 board (16 ports) for 200.00 and 2 meanwell power supplies for under 300.00. Depending how you use it, you can use alot of lights with it. There are other boards as well but as I stated I use falcon boards. So when you say I can get this board for 70.00 or so and this for..... well that adds up . The smart lights do cost more, but what you can do with them is really fun. You can make smart rgb lights dumb but you cant make dumb rgb lights smart


Reply
Page 1 / 8
Share: