LOR vs Other Contro...
 
Notifications
Clear all

LOR vs Other Controllers

7 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
5,668 Views
Posts: 2
Topic starter
(@christish2006)
New Member
Joined: 10 years ago
[#42661]

Hi All,

I'm coming back to this after a few years so things may have changed a bit. Previously I used a Renard 16 Controller and a bunch of SSR's that I built myself. While this worked reasonably well, I went with the DC option so had to make up looms for various lights and couldn't use the 240v lights etc. I think I also burnt out a couple of Triacs along the way.

This year, I was looking at getting some LOR Controllers, specifically I like their Showtime Central starter kit which allows me to have all the sequences on a SD card and comes with a 16 Channel AC Controller, FM Transmitter, Software, etc.

It's rather pricey but at least it's fairly simple and at least this year would be relatively simple to setup.

Can anyone give me the Pros and Cons, I am sure it's been asked before.

I know it's fairly late in the year, which is why I like the LOR stuff, I can buy it with pre-defined sequences on it, is it possible to do this with Vixen and other controllers?, Also I would like to make some leaping arches, and I will check the forum later, but is there a recommended controller that works well with RGB stuff and Vixen?

Cheers for any help you can provide.

Chris


6 Replies
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

LOR makes fine equipment. As you already know, Renard gear works well, too, and provides more options than most other systems do. One isn't necessarily better than the other but one may be more convenient for your situation. Either method obviously involves quite a bit of DIY because those lights and connections don't happen by themselves.

Sharing Vixen sequences *sometimes* works but understand that no two people have the same channel/controller assignments and rarely can you just drop something in and have it run. This is even more difficult now with the advent of pixels and the mega-channel-counts that are the result of it.

With small channel counts you may be able to find users who are glad to share their old Vixen 2.1 sequences, but it becomes more problematic with the newer versions of sequencers because of their object-oriented designs as opposed to rows and columns like the old Vixen 2.1

You can certainly check the file library here -- there may be some sequences there -- and use the search tools for key words such as "sharing" or "shared sequences", etc.

This is a pretty late date to get started and my guess is that most of us are busy putting the final touches on our own shows and won't have a lot of spare time to provide much help. So you'll have to do the legwork... In any event, good luck and have fun!


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago
dirknerkle wrote:
This is even more difficult now with the advent of pixels and the mega-channel-counts that are the result of it.

Sharing is easy, at least with xlights. Even if the models aren't exact, the software can scale. I don't find it anymore difficult sharing ac sequences or rgb.

Responding to the op, there is nothing wrong with LOR hardware, except maybe price. But if you are willing to pay for it, then by all means get it. I wouldn't recommend their software and as a show player I would use fpp/pi.

James

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 485
(@jerry-rigs)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago

Chris,
Welcome back.

You mention leaping arches and 16 channels of AC. Just to help establish a baseline...
A leaping arch from a few years ago: A PVC pipe wrapped with 4, 6, 8, 16, or more "segments" made of strings of lights with each segment controlled by an AC channel. It was all one color unless you multiple the number of channels by the number of colors. A single leaping arch eats a lot of channels quick.
A leaping arch from today: A PVC pipe with a pixel string attached to it or a PEX pipe with a pixel string inside it. There may be 30+ pixels in a 3 foot wide arch. Those 30 + pixels are a very small fraction of the channels available in a dedicated pixel controller.

The LOR package is ~$570 with 16 channels, a transmitter, a show controller, sequencing software, and an RJ-45 cable. Strings of lights can be as low as $2 each. Extension cords are extra.

A top of the line Pixel controller costs ~$200, a Power Supply is ~$40, a transmitter costs ~$125, software (Vixen/xLights) is free, 50 node pixels strings are ~$20 each, and the show can be run from a old laptop or a new Raspberry Pi 3 (~$35) running Falcon Pi Player. Cabling is extra.

Both routes have a lot of "incidentals" and require a significant time investment. I -think- it may be easier to buy/beg/modify simple LOR sequences but they will be kinda bland. For me, writing a sequence that I am happy with requires a lot of time but Vixen and xLights both have the ability to make -simple- sequences very quickly even for a beginner. Hell, even a pixel test pattern can look cool to the non-jaded.

With LOR, for ~$600, you can have 2 x single color, 8 segment, leaping arches.
With pixels, for ~$600, you can have 10 x rainbow colored, 25 node leaping arches.

My first entry into pixels 3 (4?) years ago was a 800 pixel (16x50) 15 ft scratch built PVC "mega"-tree. The electronics total was ~$800. Probably ~$200 for the mechanicals and incidentals.


Reply
Posts: 2
Topic starter
(@christish2006)
New Member
Joined: 10 years ago

Thanks all for your replies.

There still seems to be many options around with whatever hardware / software combo I go with.

It's probably far too late in the year, so I think maybe I will go with LOR with the pre-built sequences just to get going or maybe I'll forego the animation this year and just have some strings of static lights around. That way I can have a lot more time next year to plan.

I really am not familiar with Pixels at all and need to invest a lot more time trying to understand it. From some of the posts it looks as though Pixels may be better, but I assume that everything in terms of lighting would have to be custom built. So it may be a good idea to have both functionalities, to control both standard LED strings and Pixel stuff.

Thanks


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: