Lighting controller...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Lighting controller and software suggestions?

16 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
4,716 Views
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

The biggest difference between relays and the triac based designs (that we call SSRs) is that the SSRs are much faster than relays and can handle the very heavy duty cycles we put them under. There's probably as many on/off cycles in a 3 minute song than your pool controller might do in a week. (Beautiful panel by the way). You'd go thru your 10,000 cycles the relay is rated for in a week or two.
For reference. The Renard boards are in the bargain price category. The SS boards are functionally similar to the lor controllers, but quite a bit cheaper. An RP32 is about $35 and once you add enough SSRs to fill it up you're in for another $35 or so. So for $70 you've got 32 channels of dimming spendor! (The SS stuff is similarly priced) That's really in the same ballpark as an arduino/relay based setup. And it's already in the right form factor that you need. Yeah there's the extras like cords and enclosure and such, but those things are the same for both methods.
As far as software goes, well, being the voice of Vixen 3, I'm partial there, but there's several options. Vixen 2.1 has been the mainstay of this community for years. It's been a dead project for several years now, but still very viable for small traditional shows. LOR isn't widely used here because, well vixen 2.1 did pretty much everything it did and it's free. LSP used to be the promising front runner for modern displays, but it seems to have died on the vine in the past few years. The two biggest here are now Vixen 3 and HLS. These are both in active development. They're both very capable, but very different workflow.
Any of the options will be good for a small show. When you get bigger, or into full color, or into pixels you start looking for specific features. Some of the programs that have been around longer aren't as good at this stuff as the newer programs.

--Jon Chuchla--

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 384
(@burtonmadness)
Honorable Member
Joined: 14 years ago

I would suggest you take a few back.

Look at what lights you have already. Look at the real estate you want to play with (House Vs Garden or both), then look at whether you want to entertain wireless (with the benefits and problems it brings).

As a thought, I originally planned to create a Dumb RGB strip based North Pole. Weighing up the controller requirement for 12x3 (36 channel) controller Vs Dumb vs Smart-Pixel strips, I ended up with a single Komby RF1_12, One power supply with one point of power injection. The cost was a little cheaper with smart pixels rather than dumb pixels.

I will be taking baby steps with regards pixels elsewhere, as I don't have the sequencing skills to maximise their usage, so prefer straight blinky flashing apart from a few props with pixels (North Pole, Lanterns, Columns), with everything else mains voltage LED strings.

/Fran


Reply
Posts: 5
Topic starter
(@pipeandwire)
Active Member
Joined: 12 years ago

HOLY CRAP! wow thats a lot of different products i had no idea where out there. i will keep researching to see what will fit best with what i want to. thats a great read, thanks for the link


Reply
Posts: 928
(@arw01)
Noble Member
Joined: 13 years ago

DIYC here is Renard central, but another set of equipment to look at is pixelnet based from Falcon christmas and diylightanimation.com, all DIY, massively flexible, easier in MHO because you don't have so many universe issues to deal with, works with your decentralized concept, has all the bases covered for dmx, pixels, dumb rgb, static elements, incandescents, led etc.

For software I went straight to the top of the line stuff, LightShow Pro, it's in re-write mode this year and who knows what it will have for new stuff when it comes out, the rest of the software out there is still chasing what LSP did 3 years ago.


Reply
Posts: 5
Topic starter
(@pipeandwire)
Active Member
Joined: 12 years ago
jchuchla wrote:The biggest difference between relays and the triac based designs (that we call SSRs) is that the SSRs are much faster than relays and can handle the very heavy duty cycles we put them under. There's probably as many on/off cycles in a 3 minute song than your pool controller might do in a week. (Beautiful panel by the way). You'd go thru your 10,000 cycles the relay is rated for in a week or two.
For reference. The Renard boards are in the bargain price category. The SS boards are functionally similar to the lor controllers, but quite a bit cheaper. An RP32 is about $35 and once you add enough SSRs to fill it up you're in for another $35 or so. So for $70 you've got 32 channels of dimming spendor! (The SS stuff is similarly priced) That's really in the same ballpark as an arduino/relay based setup. And it's already in the right form factor that you need. Yeah there's the extras like cords and enclosure and such, but those things are the same for both methods.
As far as software goes, well, being the voice of Vixen 3, I'm partial there, but there's several options. Vixen 2.1 has been the mainstay of this community for years. It's been a dead project for several years now, but still very viable for small traditional shows. LOR isn't widely used here because, well vixen 2.1 did pretty much everything it did and it's free. LSP used to be the promising front runner for modern displays, but it seems to have died on the vine in the past few years. The two biggest here are now Vixen 3 and HLS. These are both in active development. They're both very capable, but very different workflow.
Any of the options will be good for a small show. When you get bigger, or into full color, or into pixels you start looking for specific features. Some of the programs that have been around longer aren't as good at this stuff as the newer programs.

--Jon Chuchla--

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

i can really appreciate any one who supports their product along with unbiased opinions of other options. i've begun a test show with vixen 3 and i have to admit i like how its layed out and how things are going so far. im overwhelmed at all the different lighting pieces are out there from the link posted by habbosrus. just need to now start going thru them and understanding what each of them do and the cost to get them. im hoping to find some shows out there where the //artist if thats what we can can them// says or lists the equipment he/she used in the show. i guess once i learn the pieces i'de know as i see them light up. but im looking forward to the whole process. i kind of need to start to figure out which direction om going in hardware wise because once christmas passes im going to want to start accumulating the lighting. and it seems like a lot to conquer in a few days. to be honest, doubt ill get that far to where im educated on what i really want or need but want to be at least a little prepared to have some savings with the sales.


Reply
Page 3 / 4
Share: