Future Direction
 
Notifications
Clear all

Future Direction

23 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
40.9 K Views
Posts: 2630
Topic starter
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
CaptKirk wrote:If a more dedicated design were done, you could still allow expansion capabilities with optional inexpensive dual Berg style connectors. Think Lynx Express 16 where you plug in the wireless board if desired, but in this case it could be anything.

I have no issue with this, but I'm starting to discover the community isn't as interested in learning as it once was. So too much flexibility is a bad thing because you have to write code, there is a balance between functions and capabilities for most they want functions.

Please also consider having as much "on board"/in-field manageability as possible. Using a simple 3 or 4 7 segment display, you could allow for status displays (the name of the board, firmware revision, etc), configuring simple things like DMX start address, and for kicking off test modes and/or set-up modes (all on, all off, ramp all up/down/repeat, cycle through one at a time, blink all, etc.). Although it adds a little bit of cost, the extra capability and usability it adds is seriously nice and really makes the controller (I cannot get anymore) one of the best DMX DIY setups out there.

For my node project I had considered adding an LCD and switches to configure it and allow for those sorts of things and scrapped it for a webpage interface. Personally I prefer the LCD but it requires an enclosure of some sort to work well and adds some to the cost. The risk here is I design it the way I like it and no one is interested. Which is what happened when I designed the PropDimmer, its got a lot of high end features that I love but no one was really into it.

It would be nice if we could also standardize on the enclosure (like a CG-1500 which I still have quite a few of, or the CG-2000 for mounting) as that makes life really easy also.

We could/should be doing this for anything that is likely to be outdoors.

Switching to a prop means ANOTHER set of programming tools I need to get stuff for and remember how to use. Oh- on board programming capability is nice also

This is a double edged sword. If we add on-board programming via USB it means SMT parts or expensive modules. If we go the serial route it means you need a serial port, which is hard to find on PCs these days. If we provide a programming header you need to purchase a $20 programmer. So then what does one do? I'm indifferent I just want to know what people prefer.


Reply
Posts: 789
(@chilloutdocdoc)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I'm not going to bash the design of "easy to configure" but really... we should only be configuring our controllers once or twice per season. I don't see the point in spending $10-30 per board in adding a LCD, or buttons, or all of this stuff, when you can simply just reflash via ICSP or Set it up with a computer.

Maybe it's the cheapskate in me.


Reply
Posts: 2630
Topic starter
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

What about a DMX/Renard/sACN (or whatever else) tester? I've been situations where I would rather use a handheld controller instead of booting my laptop or I just want to isolate a problem, this could fill both problems.


Reply
Posts: 789
(@chilloutdocdoc)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
DynamoBen wrote:What about a DMX/Renard/sACN (or whatever else) tester? I've been situations where I would rather use a handheld controller instead of booting my laptop or I just want to isolate a problem, this could fill both problems.

I would SERIOUSLY get behind this.


Reply
critic2
Posts: 1389
(@critic2)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
DynamoBen wrote:Personally I need a controller that I can reconfigure since I use them one way for Halloween and another for Christmas, so that concept will live on. But I see other Prop based projects here that are being quickly adopted by people but only a handful of folks use the PropController. So I see two groups, devs and users. Devs want flexibility but users want build and play. I guess I'm wondering if we should cater to the users since there is a high learning curve between the two groups?

BTW regardless of direction all of the code a schematics will continue to be open source.

I could go as high as 128 w/o breaking a sweat.

I am currently a user, but want to be a devs. I can't read this site quick enought!! Learning something new EVERY DAY.
I love DIYC. Yea, I'm hooked...

Chuck P.


Reply
Page 3 / 5
Share: