Noob friendly: Usin...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Noob friendly: Using a Powerline with the controller

7 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
1,915 Views
Posts: 13
 v3x
Topic starter
(@v3x)
Eminent Member
Joined: 8 years ago
[#54514]

I was curious why I have never seen anyone use a Powerline in their enclosures. Is it a bad idea?

My understanding is I would be able to build multiple enclosures and have one adapter in each and they will all communicate together without needing an ethernet cable.

For those who do not know, a Powerline uses your home electricity cables to transfer ethernet data. One adapter is connected to your router, and the other(s) anywhere on your home power grid. It is quite useful for people with WiFi signal problems.

My reason for using a Powerline is that I was never able to get my R.PI with FPP to work properly. After many hours of frustration I gave up and bought this and it worked instantly, hence my topic. Figured it would be worthy for someone reading up on DIY lights and feeling overwhelmed that they could use an easier option. For my 4 previous years, I have been using Vixen and would put my sequence on a MicroSD card and used the standalone player directly on the Falcon. This year I am using xLights for the first time and wanted a direct connection from my PC without having to pass an extra long cable through a wall.

In my CG-1500 I have 2xMeanwell PSU's, FalconF16v3 and the Powerline adapter that I linked above. I also bought a small left angle ethernet cable because I couldn't close the door.


6 Replies
MartinMueller2003
Posts: 7614
(@martinmueller2003)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 14 years ago

Ethernet over Powerlines adds delay which results in lag. You might be able to tune the system to compensate but it adds a layer of uncertainty in the show. Since the FPP running on a PI is a stable configuration and you could not make it work, then you need to look at how your network is set up. FYI: I use these devices in my home for a few systems like the ones in my sheds and a TV that is in a tough location for WiFi.


Reply
Posts: 13
 v3x
Topic starter
(@v3x)
Eminent Member
Joined: 8 years ago
MartinMueller2003 wrote:you need to look at how your network is set up.

Absolutely! I won't deny that I suck at networking. I have watched many YT videos and nothing seemed to work for me. I had an easy option out and took it.

MartinMueller2003 wrote:Ethernet over Powerlines adds delay which results in lag.

Again, you must be right. This is something that I have never really considered. But then again, I am new to this hobby and I am not sequencing my lights to music so it's a non-issue for me at this point. I live in an apartment in a big city and cannot really think about playing music for everyone to hear 8 hours a day. Bad things might happen...


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I applaud your efforts to use a different method for data communication.

Sometimes in this hobby you'll run into comments and criticisms by others who've been around for a while that seem to pooh-pooh an idea or method, but if it works for you, then what the heck! Use it! There are a great many ways to make a light show work and have fun doing it at the same time. That's what DIY is all about!

Anyway, way to go! I love to see folks trying different things, and when they're successful, that's even better!


Reply
Posts: 3735
(@algerdes)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago

To echo what Dirknerkle said:

Give it a try! Things change and earlier experiments may not have been in the same environment that you are working in. Our "knowledge" may be skewed by the times we were living in when we gave it a try.

Powerline based communications has some great potential. Early experiments with it were hampered by slow speeds, lag in transmission, and a few other things. Current hardware should have taken care of some, if not all of the "problems" we saw in the beginning.

Please keep us informed! Sounds like it has potential!


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: