budude wrote:Why would you need a direct connection to a show computer - seems like normal switching like we use today should still apply?
According to the PDF he attached, a full IP stack isn't implemented.
Zeph wrote:Could you sketch out some of your ideas for the FPGA programming, ideally for those of us not already expert with those devices?For example, to control a ws2811, you will need some kind of logic which recognizes when an ethernet packet is received, checks certain bytes to see that it's valid, sorts out the universe, then fetches bytes from the ethernet buffer and serially encodes them with appropriate clock rates, to the right output ports, right? Or...?
I'm guessing that you will not buffer more than a byte at a time within the FPGA, and will use buffer memory on the ethernet interface to hold the brightness data, right?
Will you use some sort of state machine to step through the packet bytes, comparing some bytes to mandatory patterns, ignoring others, and getting universe data from other; if everything's OK, you will copy the data payload out.
Will this send to a single output string (universe) output at a time, or will it send to multiple universes overlapped? In the latter case, that might involve separate state machines for each universe, which interleave their accesses to the buffer RAM on the ethernet interface?
Is there any way to configure to send less than a universe out to a pixel string?
The FPGA that he is using has over 20Kbytes of on-chip memory, so my guess is that he copies data from the Ethernet chip memory into that on-chip memory. This is not so different from a project that I've worked on several times over the last decade or so, briefly described here. I might even be able to find the design files for those projects. At the time it seemed better to implement those types of projects using micros, so I ended up shelving the project.
budude wrote:Why would you need a direct connection to a show computer - seems like normal switching like we use today should still apply?
I'm not so sure that he literally means 'a direct connection', i.e. without an intervening Ethernet switch. The comment about not supporting IGMP suggests that a 'direct connection' is meant as the opposite of multi-cast operation (i.e. uni-cast).
P. Short wrote:I'm not so sure that he literally means 'a direct connection', i.e. without an intervening Ethernet switch. The comment about not supporting IGMP suggests that a 'direct connection' is meant as the opposite of multi-cast operation (i.e. uni-cast).
Hmm - don't get that out of that - you don't need IGMP for multicast (yes - it's better to have it - but not required) - - none of the E68x controllers use it for example. I'm not sure how else you would read "requiring to connect directly to the show computer and gobble up an ethernet port may kill it for some" other than a physical direct connection? Whether the OP meant that is left for him to answer I guess...
