XBee vs. ESP?
 
Notifications
Clear all

XBee vs. ESP?

7 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
2,878 Views
scottmcm
Posts: 621
Topic starter
(@scottmcm)
Prominent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#47627]

I threw in the towel this year on flicker issues with my XBee setup. The exact same setup from last year that was 99.9% perfect was absolutely unbearable this year. I did not have time or desire to try and fix it so I just got out my crimper and box of Cat5 and made some long cables.

I still like the wireless controller concept though and have been reading up on ESP. The thing I am wondering is does ESP have similar flicker issues as with XBee? It would seem not because of the way it works and I have not seen anyone mention it in threads so here I am, asking the group. Anyone have any thoughts on this? Thanks!


6 Replies
Posts: 64
(@oceanwanderlust)
Trusted Member
Joined: 13 years ago

I think a lot of hobbyists gave up on XBee / Zigbee for Christmas lights or anything else, the moment they discovered ESP!


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

XBee still is a viable wireless platform and the newest firmware is quite good. Tweist (Twireless at the green site) is using it for his 30+ home neighborhood display after consulting with the Digi people on the best ways to eliminate interference and flicker issues. Digi has had a lot more experience with it since they acquired Maxstream, originators of the XBee radio about 7 years ago, too. Exacerbating the whole issue is the marked increase in wi-fi and iOT devices, all of which operate in the same 2.4ghz radio spectrum. For example, I ran a site survey from my Ubiquiti Nanostation Loco M2 that's mounted in the front of my house and it found 53 networks with a viable signal strength that could become problematic. And that's just Wi-Fi and doesn't include garage door openers, cordless phones, dog collars, and wireless security systems.

Here are some new things they suggest -- and these are also in reference to the newest firmware (version 10ef). Since Tweist implemented these, he says his interference/flickers have dropped to virtually zero:

Channel: 17
MAC mode: 802.15.4 no ACKs
XBee retries: 0
Coordinator enable: End Device
Data rate: 57600
Parity: No Parity
Packetization Timeout: 0
API Enable: API Disabled
DI07: Disabled
DI05: Disabled
I/O Output Enable: Disabled
I/O Input Address: FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF

Some of these are typically Enabled on a default system. Their new firmware actually does something with them to enhance communication. Disabling the DI07, DI05 and I/O Output Enable are also new settings for us insofar as they prevent any of the other radios in the show from inadvertently transmitting something out on the same channel and PANID because having more than one transmitter on the same channel and network will obviously be problematic.

This is all not to say that the ESP revolution isn't quite something! I am currently running both my XBee network and an ESP network and am finding no problems running them concurrently, and that's with about 32 XBees and 43 ESPs out in the field. In many cases I'm running parallel channels just to check performance and the only difference I've found is that the Xbee seems to work better over longer distances and has a more omnidirectional antenna orientation. On the other hand, the ESP provides additional addressing capabilities that can be changed remotely from a browser without having to reflash a PIC with new firmware. And, of course, the price differential between XBee and ESP makes changing to an ESP system much easier on the bank account....


Reply
Posts: 446
(@amigorick)
Honorable Member
Joined: 16 years ago

Would these settings need to be programmed on all Xbees in the system or just the transmitting Xbee?


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

All of them. Remember, all XBees on the same PANID/network use the same settings.


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: