Does anybody have any suggestions for pixel spacing for a matrix using RGB strips?
I am looking at using http://www.diyledexpress.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=42_44&products_id=176
I want to make a matrix the 5m long with 18 strips horizontally. The question is how far should I space them so it doesn't look squashed or stretched out as it displays text. I am hoping the entire dimension will work out to 4' wide by 16' long but want to be sure I get the spacing at a reasonable level.
Any advise would be greatly appreciated.
Electrified3 wrote:Does anybody have any suggestions for pixel spacing for a matrix using RGB strips?
The most common spacing of WS2811 LED strip itself appears to be .65" (60/m) or 1.3" (30/m). If you are wanting a 1:1 aspect ratio (ie, same horizontal and vertical spacing), then that or a multiple of it would be the approximate spacing to use between strips.
Electrified3 wrote:I want to make a matrix the 5m long with 18 strips horizontally. The question is how far should I space them so it doesn't look squashed or stretched out as it displays text.
How good it looks depends somewhat on what type of graphics or effects you will be using.
18 strips spanning a 4' width would require ~ 2.8" spacing between strips. That would give you apprximately a 2:1 aspect ratio if you are using 30 LED/m (1.3" spacing), which might be okay depending on the type of effects or graphics you want to use. If you wanted closer to 1:1 aspect ratio you could shorten the strips down to ~ 5.5' (cut them into thirds), and that would give you 3 * 18 = 54 of them, so you would end up with a 50 x 54 matrix that is about 5.5' x 5.8'.
A tedious way to get more coverage from the LED strips is to cut on all the cut points and solder in short wires. For example, if you spaced them out to 2" then you could make a 100 x 27 matrix that would cover approx 16' x 4'. This would give you custom spacing between the LEDs, trading off time for $.
don
Ideally you want the pixels as 'square' as possible. In other words pixel separation on the horizontal and vertical axis should be equal. 30 pixels per meter is roughly 1 pixel every 1.3". If you want your display to be 48" high then you should have about 36 horizontal strips.
You need to consider viewing distance also. 1.3" pixel spacing is probably best viewed at 100' or so if your goal is to display an image (ie a picture as opposed to text or simple graphics).
If you can, I think you will have better luck if you change your aspect ratio. 4'x8', with 1.3" spacing both ways. would give you an array that is 75 pixels wide and 36 pixels tall. You could dis[play some pretty decent images on that.
There is a sign down the road from me that uses a 25mm x 30mm pitch and it looks fine. Also, the old analog TV had non-square pixels of 4:3 ratio. When I first started looking at lights there was a company that made their own flexible LED strips, and they had video's of the lights with 6 inch spacing between the strands and it looked fine, can't find the link. They had to, cause at $250 a string means most people would not buy a lot of them. The issue to me is keeping the proportions of the things that you are displaying. Since Nutcracker only currently support square pixels, it is easier to make your pixels square. Otherwise you have to author all of your own effects.
I have a video of both 30 and 60 LED's per meter. Also, there is a guy that did a full garage display on 2 inch centers. Search around and look for his video. I think I would stick with the flexible strips because they have a low resistance and they are easier to work with.
ron
Posted to Nutcracker that they add variable pixel pitch to the horizontal and vertical signs.
Guys, does it make any difference if I group in 2 LED's to each pixel(2 leds to each group) horizontally? Say grouping of 2 with 30 LED/m (1.3" spacing), Does this make my effective ratio of 1:1 now 2.6" as center gaps using xlights or nutcracker? I am looking at the strip width of .55" + 2" which I think would give me 2.6: 2.55? Close enough to 1:1 ratio I would think if that is so critical?
Just a quick FYI, images are not of any concern to me, legible text at 100' with background effects is.
Does this make any sense or am I missing something??
Electrified3 wrote:Say grouping of 2 with 30 LED/m (1.3" spacing), Does this make my effective ratio of 1:1 now 2.6" as center gaps using xlights or nutcracker?
If you used 2 LEDs for each pixel, yes, that would basically give you 2.6" spacing. The down side would be that it uses 2x as much power for the same number of pixels (unless you dimmed them or turned off every other one), and it costs 2x as much, but it does give a more convenient spacing. I'm using this approach on some of my props.
(I'm not sure how Nutcracker handles grouping, but if it doesn't let you group then you could just copy or duplicate channels).
don
Here is the link for the full garage matrix I think Ron is talking about.
Lit up a 60 pixel per meter string, using every other pixel line and double pixels on each line. At 50 feet it was very readable, which should be equivalent to your setup at 100 feet. Also very readable at the back of my yard at about 70 feet. I would post the pictures, but they did not turn out well.
